Silent Mercy ac-13 Read online

  “Sorry for my ignorance, Mike. Who are they?”

  “That’s Saints Paul and Peter, holding the Keys to the Kingdom. Then you’ve got the four apostles — John, Luke, Mark, and Matthew.”

  The artistry of the glasswork was extraordinary.

  “Now, here’s what got me thinking, Coop. You remember where the body was this morning?”

  “Between two old headstones, and beneath the window that depicted Matthew.”

  “Exactly. Manny Chirico was fixated on the names on grave markers for clues, but I kept thinking about the portraits in the stained glass, ’cause there was something unusual about that image.”

  “In what way?”

  “I mean, most of the time — in Christian art — the apostles are portrayed like this.” Mike was at his most animated, taking me by the hand to stand before these masterpieces of religious glasswork. “See? Each of them is painted with one of the living creatures described in the book of Revelation.”

  The larger-than-life-size evangelists were posed on golden pedestals, and at their bases were bright blue enamel medallions — the same color as their halos — bearing their names.

  “So that’s John, with an eagle at his feet,” I said. “Mark with a lion, Luke beside a bull, and then—”

  “That’s what was different at St. Pat’s,” Mike said, breaking into my sentence as we stood beneath the stunning portrait of the fourth apostle. “There were no beasts, no creatures in those windows. But look, Coop, look at this.”

  The French medallion below the figure in the fourth soaring window bore the name Matthieu.

  He was robed in magenta, composing his gospel, pen in hand, as he gazed toward heaven. Holding the emerald-green writing tablet for him and glancing back at us was a young man — a young man with wings on his back, feathered and tipped with gold.

  “A winged man,” I said in a whisper.

  “He’s gaming us, this killer. Somehow he got himself over the gates at Mount Neboh—”

  “Like Luther Audley said, the guy flew.”

  “Well, he did it again this morning, into the graveyard. At least, that’s what he wants us to believe.”

  “Like the symbolism at the fountain at St. John the Divine, when you asked me about the flying guy in the statue,” I said, visualizing the Archangel Michael, hovering over a decapitated Satan.

  “Yeah.”

  “You’re thinking that the killer left the body at St. Pat’s this morning, and cut out her tongue. You’re thinking he brought it here. That he knew about the connection between the two churches because of the windows, because of the classic portraits of the apostles.”

  Mike nodded at me.

  “But he couldn’t possibly have known there’d be a homicide cop at the scene who’d worshipped in this very chapel,” I said, brushing off the idea that had seized both of us so completely. “No one could expect this to be put together so quickly.”

  “Of course not, Coop. But this bastard is showing off how well he knows his Bible, his religious readings, the haunts of the faithful — like this little jewel of a sleepy village church, with its legendary royal windows,” Mike said. “Forget about me piecing this together—”

  “But you did.”

  “Yeah. And by the time Commissioner Scully sits down with the cardinal tonight to talk about the desecration at Old St. Pat’s, you can bet the cardinal himself will make the very same connection. This is well-documented church history, kid, even if it’s news to you. Keith Scully went to Fordham Law School. He’d have this figured out even if I was walking a beat in Coney Island,” Mike said. “See that altar right there?”

  I’d forgotten the police commissioner had a Fordham Law degree. I nodded as Mike pointed to the rear of the church where a decorative piece, elaborately carved with a relief of the Last Supper, stood next to the entrance.

  “Yes. It looks like it came out of a museum.”

  “Well, it’s the original altar from Old St. Pat’s, and it was installed here by Cardinal Spellman in the 1940s, a gift from the archdiocese. I may have encroached on a bit of the killer’s lead time, but the church hierarchy would have come to the same conclusion and connected that cathedral to this little chapel before the sun sets tonight.”

  “So you’re right, Mike. The perp’s gaming us and he’s gaming the whole religious establishment as well. What are you doing now?”

  Mike was running his hand along the wall, back and forth below Matthew’s window. “One more thought. I was looking for a crevice, a hiding place — but the stained glass is mounted flush into the wall.”

  Although the window’s elevation stretched almost to the ceiling, its bottom was not much higher than our heads.

  “You still think?…”

  “One more place. There’s a reliquary here, at the end of the east transept. A shrine to Saint Jean de Brébeuf. There’s a Frenchman for you.”

  I jogged to try to catch up with Mike.

  “He was a Jesuit priest who was captured by the Iroquois and tortured to death,” Mike said. “Mutilated.”

  That sort of eliminated any questions I had about why this would be a fitting place for a connection to our victim.

  “He was so brave he never even whimpered during the torture,” Mike said, before he turned away from me again. “So the Iroquois cut out his heart and ate it, to try to internalize his courage.”

  The reliquary was in the darkest recess of the church, marked by a small plaque that listed the other martyred Jesuit priests it honored. It was mounted high on the wall. On a shelf beneath it, far above us, was a silver chalice, like the kind used at communion.

  Mike stood as tall as he could but wasn’t able to reach the shelf.

  “What are you doing?” I asked as he ran past me and up the steps of the main altar.

  “Stay put.”

  He disappeared through one of the doorways to the right, and less than a minute later emerged carrying a wooden ladder I guessed to be six feet tall.

  “What?. .”

  “Watch it, Coop. Every altar boy needs a boost now and then to get up to the candelabra to put out the flames. There’s always a ladder backstage.”

  I steadied the legs as Mike climbed the steps. Directly over his head there was a crossbeam, closer to the ledge of the reliquary than he could get with his outstretched arm. I closed my eyes for a second and imagined a winged man suspended from it. The exhaustion was playing tricks with my imagination.

  “Get me closer,” he said.

  I pushed the ladder slowly so as not to dislodge him.

  Mike reached out again and grasped the stem of the chalice. He glanced into it, then pulled it to his chest to secure it, holding it there with his right hand while he guided himself down the rungs with his left.

  When he had both feet on the floor, he extended the silver cup toward me. There within it was the discolored, putrefied tongue of the woman who’d been murdered at Old St. Patrick’s Cathedral earlier that day.

  TWENTY-TWO

  IT was almost five o’clock when Mike dropped me off at the Hogan Place entrance to the District Attorney’s Office. Lawyers were pushing shopping carts full of case folders and evidence back from courtrooms in the overflow civil courthouse across Centre Street, ending wearying days on trial. I crowded into an elevator with two of the junior assistants and rode up to the eighth-floor office suites.

  “Hey, Laura. Start with the good news.”

  “Can’t think of any. You’re going to need a shovel to get through all the stuff that’s been piling up since you left.”

  “Battaglia?”

  “Better send out for a cocktail before you go in there. Something to steady your nerves. He’s been like a raging bull today.”

  “Now?”

  “Go rescue Nan. She and McKinney have been in with him for an hour.”

  “Take off. See you tomorrow.”

  “Not a prayer. You need an air-traffic controller for these messages. I’ll wait till you’re out
.”

  “Thanks.” I picked up a legal pad and headed through security to the executive wing. Rose looked as grim as an executioner.

  Pat McKinney practically exploded with delight when Battaglia, who was talking on the phone, scowled at my entrance. “What was it? Chapman’s class reunion that took you back to the Bronx?”

  “And to think Mike didn’t invite you to come along, Patrick. You could have been homecoming queen.”

  News of our important find hadn’t reached the DA yet, or McKinney wouldn’t have been quite so snide about my absence.

  I sat next to Nan at the conference table and leaned over to whisper to her. “I am so sorry to have dragged you into this mess.”

  “I’ll get you back,” she said, patting my hand. “You’ll owe me for months.”

  “Alexandra will be a little late for that meeting, Keith,” Battaglia said, crushing the cigar with his teeth as he raised his voice. “We’ve got some business here first.”

  Battaglia had been talking to Commissioner Scully. I didn’t know whether that would be worse for Mike or for me, since we had both disappeared for the afternoon.

  “So what else does your crystal ball tell you?” McKinney asked. “You sure nailed that St. Pat’s location for the second body.”

  I didn’t answer. I was most anxious to ask Battaglia to find out from Bishop Deegan who the man in the courtroom during his testimony was. I was certain I had seen him at St. John the Divine the day before, but for the first time in my years under Battaglia’s watch, I worried about giving up information like that when there was clearly a backstory between the district attorney and the bishop to which I was not privy.

  “They had a solution for that kind of prognosticating in Salem,” McKinney said. He was, as usual, the only one to laugh at what he thought passed for humor.

  “Nan was just telling us that there might be a Bellevue connection,” Battaglia said, eyeing me, waiting for me to speak.

  “Mercer come up with anything solid yet?” I asked her.

  “Risk management’s doing their usual dance,” she said, referring to the legal arm of the hospital, always vigilant against the potential for lawsuits. “Patient privacy, medical privilege — we’ll be lucky to have our first shot at records by Monday.”

  “Surely Chapman’s got a hot nurse or two he can lean on there to break the rules,” McKinney said.

  “I won’t forget to ask him.”

  “Scully’s having the Homicide Squad bosses in at six for a briefing. He wants you there,” Battaglia said.

  I was certain McKinney had been lobbying to take me off the case. His girlfriend had just been dumped from the head of the Gun Recovery Unit for general incompetence, and Pat kept looking to insert her into other high-profile work. The fact that he hadn’t dragged her into this mess suggested he didn’t have any ready solutions for these murders and feared things would get worse before we made headway.

  “All right if Nan comes along?” I asked.

  “I’d prefer it. At least I can find her when I need something.” Battaglia had good reason to respect Nan’s professionalism. She had tried some of the most challenging cases — from murder to multimillion-dollar white-collar frauds — and was one of his most trusted soldiers.

  Chapman obviously hadn’t reached Scully yet. “Just so you know, Mike didn’t take me on a wild goose chase. We found what we were looking for.”

  “Are you serious? He found the woman’s tongue?” The DA put his hand on the black phone that connected him immediately to the police commissioner’s desk. “Tell me where it was. I can hold this one over the PC’s head.”

  I explained what had led Mike to the campus chapel. A smile crept onto Paul Battaglia’s face. He liked the church trivia and the forensic finding almost as much as he relished being the first in a position of power to know something.

  “I’ve got a slew of calls to make before I go over to headquarters,” I said, rising to leave. “We left Crime Scene at the chapel going over every inch of the place. The killer must have gone straight from St. Pat’s cemetery up to Fordham.”

  “I can head out from here,” Nan said. “I’ll tell Mike you’ll be over in?…”

  “By the time the meeting starts.”

  We left McKinney with Battaglia and Nan asked me if I needed help with anything before she took the short walk from our office, through the cutaway next to the federal courthouse, to One Police Plaza, tucked away behind the United States Attorney’s Office.

  “Thanks. Laura’s going to hang out and triage my list of calls. See you there.”

  I went back to my office. Laura had just brewed a fresh pot of coffee and set me up with a steaming-hot mug.

  Six of the lawyers from the unit were on trial. Only two had courtroom crises, and my longtime deputy had put out those fires. I clipped the notes together to take home with me, so I could check in on each of them that night.

  There were case inquiries from victims, detectives who wanted investigative guidance, and one bureau chief complaining about a judgment call we had made in a new case. My internist’s office reminded me of the need for an annual checkup, my nephew wanted theater tickets when the family came to town for spring break, and a date had been set for the fall trunk show at Escada. It seemed that everyone but the man I loved was looking for me.

  “This guy was beyond rude,” Laura said, handing me a slip with her red exclamation marks and underlining all over it. “Let him cool down a day before you call.”

  The message was from Vincenzo Borracelli. My meeting with his wife had only been Thursday but felt like a week ago. “It’s imperative that I hear from you today. Do you know who I am?” The italics were Laura’s — it meant that Borracelli had been screaming at her. “You can’t treat my child the way you did. I’ll have you taken off the case at once. I’ll see that you pay for this.”

  “Good luck to him if he can find someone else who wants the case,” I said, handing the slip of paper back to Laura. “Let him stew until Monday. I’ll return some of these others. Can you please remind me when it gets close to six?”

  “Will do.”

  I picked up my private line to deal with the more important matters and let Laura continue to fend off callers and passersby. I slipped a couple of Tylenol from my desk drawer and tried to make a list of details that might be useful for Scully’s meeting.

  When Laura told me it was time to go, I left all the papers in discrete piles on my desk. We both put on jackets and walked to the elevator. She went into the revolving door first, and we parted on the sidewalk in front of the Hogan Place entrance.

  “Good night. Stop pushing yourself so hard, Alex,” Laura said, walking off to head north to the Canal Street subway station.

  “Thanks for everything. See you tomorrow.”

  I took the shortcut along Baxter Street, crossing to avoid the loading dock that was blocked by a large truck. The small park that separated Chinatown from the courthouse was on my left. Schoolchildren who played kickball and tag there were long gone, and it was too dark for the seniors who did their Tai Chi exercises at the beginning and end of the day.

  The wind picked up and shadows from the trees in the park danced under the dim glow of the streetlights.

  I held my cell in both hands, texting Mike that I was on my way. I had forgotten that the new security system at One Police Plaza would slow me down by an additional five or six minutes.

  I heard the footsteps before the man spoke. He came rushing out of the park after I passed the gate in the southwest corner, running at me from behind.

  I turned to look at him and stumbled on the cracked sidewalk, falling to my knees, my BlackBerry skipping off the curb between two parked cars.

  He was coming at me so fast that his feet caught on my extended leg and he landed on the ground, half of him squarely on top of me.

  “Ms. Alice,” the slight young black man said. “I’m not going to hurt you, Ms. Alice.”

  I didn’t realize I had
screamed until two uniformed cops pulled the kid off and cuffed him.

  TWENTY-THREE

  “IT was Luther Audley,” I said to Mike. I was forty-five minutes late for Scully’s meeting, but the commissioner himself had been called to City Hall to explain things to the mayor, so we were all on hold waiting for him.

  “How’d you recognize Luther? By the crack in his rear end?”

  Guido Lentini, the deputy commissioner for public information, had given us his office to use until Scully arrived. Nan was standing behind me, kneading my shoulders. She knew I was rattled and was just trying to calm me down.

  “Where is he now?” Mercer asked.

  “I asked the cops not to arrest him. I believe his story. I’m fine. If I hadn’t tripped on that jagged piece of cement, he wouldn’t have become entangled with me.”

  “C’mon, Alex. Where’s Luther?”

  “I told them you’d call. It’s two guys from the Ninth Precinct,” I said, unfolding a piece of paper with their numbers. “They’re holding him in Central Booking till after we sort this out.”

  “What did Luther say to you, exactly?” Mike asked.

  “He might have been calling my name to get my attention. I’m not sure, but I thought he said ‘Alice’ so it didn’t concern me. Anyway, I thought it was street noise and I ignored it ’cause I was texting you. I didn’t hear him speak until after—”

  “After he brought you down.”

  “He didn’t bring me down, Mike. I really don’t think that’s what he had in mind.”

  “He was waiting for you, wasn’t he?”

  “How could he possibly have known I’d take Baxter Street?”

  “Your office is the only place he’d think to find you,” Mercer said. “Maybe he just skulked around till he figured you’d be getting out of work, saw you walk out and separate from Laura, and got lucky when you took the darker route.”

  “But he didn’t do anything to me.”